Search
JOIN OUR NETWORK

     

     

 

 

ARTICLE ARCHIVE

Nuclear Costs

Estimates for new reactor construction costs continue to sky-rocket. Conservative estimates range between $6 and $12 billion per reactor but Standard & Poor's predicts a continued rise. The nuclear power industry is lobbying for heavy federal subsidization including unlimited loan guarantees but the Congressional Budget Office predicts the risk of default will be well over 50 percent, leaving taxpayers to foot the bill. Beyond Nuclear opposes taxpayer and ratepayer subsidies for the nuclear energy industry.

.................................................................................................................................................................................................................

Entries from June 1, 2019 - June 30, 2019

Saturday
Jun152019

Before the Ohio State Senate: Opponent Hearings on House Bill 6, the Nuclear Bailout Bill

Thank you to Ned Ford in Ohio, and Becca Pollard of Sierra Club, for sharing this news:

As indicated [below], Opponents [to House Bill 6 next] Tuesday, at 9:30 [a.m., oppoent testimony] and all parties [(opponent, proponent, and interested party testimony)] Wednesday after Session (correct me if I'm wrong but I think the earliest this could be is 3:00, and more likely a little later, but we don't know.)

Do not forget to forward the witness slip if you intend to testify.

- Ned

Good afternoon,

Please see the attached Senate Energy and Public Utilities Committee notices for next week. We will be meeting on Tuesday, June 18th at 9:30am and Wednesday, June 19th after session. All committee meetings will take place in the Finance Hearing Room.

All testimony and completed witness slips [linked below] should be submitted to the Chairman’s office no later than 24 hours prior to the scheduled committee time. Please send your testimony and completed witness slip to Libby.Hildebrandt@ohiosenate.gov. The Chairman reserves the right to limit the length of testimony. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to reach out to our office.

Thanks and have a great weekend!

Libby

Libby Hildebrandt
Senior Legislative Aide
Senator Steve Wilson – 7th District
(614) 466-9737| Libby.Hildebrandt@ohiosenate.gov

Link to 6.18.2019 Notice

Link to 6.19.2019 Notice

EPU Witness Slip

Saturday
Jun152019

Harvey Wasserman, Solartopia: TV, Radio & Print on Ohio Nuke Bailout

Ohio bailout debate on RT-TV:  

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=934hOf9-VTg&list=PLagVUKF7CUTTtjJqFw6JvO14pG6Z1RBmv

 

Radio Tutorial on Ohio Bailout:

Dick Munson/Kevin Kamps/Tim Judson/Harvey Wasserman one-hour PRN.FM Solartopia show on Ohio bailout:

 https://greenpowerwellnessshow.podbean.com/e/solartopia-green-power-and-wellness-hour-atomic-thievery-in-ohio/

 

Ohio's "Chernobyl Socialism" Would Hand $20 Million to Seven Utility Scammers

By Harvey Wasserman, Reader Supported News

10 June 19

 

https://readersupportednews.org/opinion2/277-75/57020-rsn-ohios-qchernobyl-socialismq-would-hand-20-million-to-seven-utility-scammers

 huge proposed bailout of two Chernobyl-in-progress Ohio nukes (plus two old coal burners) would put $20 million directly into the pockets of seven utility executives. Their bankrupt company last year spent $3 million “lobbying” the legislature. 

Akron’s bankrupt FirstEnergy (FE) owns the Perry nuke, east of Cleveland, which in 1986 became the first US reactor damaged by an earthquake. Critical pipes and concrete were cracked, as were nearby roads and bridges. A top-level state study showed soon thereafter that evacuation amidst a major accident would be impossible. 

FE’s uninsured Davis-Besse nuke, near Toledo, is a 42-year-old Three Mile Island clone. In 2002, boric acid ate through its head, threatening a Chernobyl-scale accident irradiating Toledo, Cleveland, and the Great Lakes. At FE’s request, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission has exempted Davis-Besse from vital regulations for flooding, fire protection, earthquake vulnerability, and security. Its radiation shield building is literally crumbling. 

In 2003, when nearby power lines sagged onto tree limbs, FirstEnergy blacked out some 50 million people throughout the northeast and well into Canada. 

By then, FE had scammed Ohio for some $9 billion in “stranded cost” bailouts. The utility said “open market competition” would lower rates ... after it pocketed the public’s money. 

Now FE says its subsidized nukes can’t compete with gas and wind power. It wants $190 million/year or more from all Ohio ratepayers, even though most get zero nuke electricity. 

FE first said the money was for “clean air” and “zero emission reactors.” But all nukes emit heat, chemicals, radiation, Carbon 14, and more. Their cooling towers kill birds, their waste hot water kills marine life, their cores (at about 300 degrees Centigrade) heat the planet. 

The bailout bill, called HB6, attacks renewable and efficiency programs that have saved Ohio ratepayers billions of dollars and created thousands of jobs. A single sentence in the Ohio Code is blocking some $4 billion in turbine development. 

The breezy “North Coast” region along Lake Erie is crisscrossed with transmission lines and good sites near urban consumers. Farmers throughout the flat, fertile agricultural land desperately want the income turbine leases could provide. The new projects would create thousands of construction and maintenance jobs. They would feed Ohio’s manufacturing base, which produces a wide range of wind and solar components. By lowering electric rates, they would restore a competitive position long lost to high electric rates. Indiana, Michigan, New York, and Pennsylvania all have at least double Ohio’s installed wind capacity. Texas has twenty times more. By 2022, Germany will be totally nuke-free. 

Ohio has just been shaken by findings that significant radiation has leaked from a dead uranium plant in southern Ohio, contaminating schools and terrifying local residents. 

Like that old “stranded cost” scam, FE’s new bailouts would suck desperately needed capital from Ohio’s faltering industrial base. The reactors are obsolete. The workforce is aging. The nukes will shut anyway … if they don’t blow up first. 

FE is really protecting its huge executive salaries. In 2018, it spent $3 million on “lobbying.” Its top seven officers, who bankrupted the company, were collectively paid more than $20,000,000, more than 10% of the proposed bailout: 

Charles E. Jones Jr., President & CEO: $9,858,109; 

Leila L. Vespoli, EVP, Corporate Strategy, Regulatory Affairs & Chief Legal Officer: $3,801,639; 

James F. Pearson, EVP, Finance: $3,840,576; 

Donald R. Schneider, President, FE Solutions: $2,343,232; 

Steven E. Strah, SVP & CFO: $2,798,523; 

Bennett L. Gaines, SVP, Corporate Services & Chief Information Officer: $1,442,149; 

Samuel L. Belcher, SVP & President, FE Utilities: $3,004,019. 

The Ohio House has already ignored extensive anti-bailout public testimony (see mine at https://ohiochannel.org/video/ohio-house-energy-and-natural-resources-committee-5-22-2019) and voted 53-43 to keep those executive handouts soaring.

The bill now moves to the Senate and its gerrymandered GOP majority. Ohio’s corporate-owned governor has assured FE he’ll approve their bailout. 

Ohio consumers may then join lawsuits against similar bailouts in New York, New Jersey, and elsewhere. A referendum, which they might well win, is also possible. 

Meanwhile, millionaire utility execs everywhere will see if the Buckeye State can be suckered again into bailing out two obsolete, cash-sucking nukes on the brink of catastrophic collapse. 

Stay tuned.

Harvey Wasserman's Green Power & Wellness Show is podcast at prn.fm; California Solartopia is broadcast at KPFK-Pacifica, 90.7 fm, Los Angeles. His book The People’s Spiral of US History: From Deganawidah to Solartopia will soon be at www.solartopia.org.

Saturday
Jun152019

Nuclear energy not emissions-free, too lethal 

Friday
Jun142019

No More Pork for FirstEnergy Solutions! Rally in Medina, OH, Tues., June 18th!

Ohio Citizen Action announcement:

[See the Ohio Citizen Action press release, here.]

No More Pork for FirstEnergy Solutions!

Giant Inflatable Pig Will Remind Medina Residents That FirstEnergy Solutions Wants to Break the Bank!

WHAT: Rally in Opposition to House Bill 6

Opportunity for Citizen Testimony on the Legislation

WHO: Ohio Consumers Power Alliance, Ohio Citizen Action

WHEN: Tuesday, June 18, 2019

12:00 to 1:00 PM

WHERE: Medina Public Square

Medina's Historic District

VISUALS:

25-foot tall inflatable pink pig

Signs, citizen activists

Area elected officials speaking

[See the Ohio Citizen Action press release here.]

Thursday
Jun132019

Coalition Against Nuclear Bailouts Press Clips

Thanks to David Hughes of Citizen Power for sharing these press clips:

From: Steve Kratz [mailto:kratz@thebravogroup.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2019 1:32 PM
To: Steven Kratz
Subject: CANB Press Clips

 

Utility Dive - BRIEF
As Ohio Senate nears vote on nuke subsidy bill, PJM finds closing plants could save $1.6B

https://www.utilitydive.com/news/as-ohio-senate-nears-vote-on-nuke-subsidy-bill-pjm-finds-closing-plants-co/556397/
Catherine Morehouse
June 10, 2019

A report from the PJM Interconnection finds that retiring current nuclear plants as scheduled in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Ohio and adding new natural gas and renewables would save $1.6 billion and 4.3 million tons of carbon, assuming 11.9 GW of coal also retires across the PJM region.

The report lays out three scenarios and finds that keeping the nuclear plants online would save consumers $2.1 billion and 19.4 million tons of carbon, but does not include the cost of subsidizing the plants, which is expected to cost $190 million annually through 2026. It was presented to the Ohio state Senate Committee on Energy and Public Utilities Wednesday as the Senate tees up its vote on the state's coal and nuclear support bill, which passed the House in May. 

House Bill 6 has been criticized for providing subsidies to First Energy Solutions' nuclear plants and critics note the report doesn't account for those subsidies or other potential impacts of the bill. Other critics say the report doesn't value nuclear enough by not accounting for the social cost of carbon. But PJM intentionally left out the cost of subsidies because "we don't control that number ... we leave that to others," PJM spokesperson Jeffrey Shields told Utility Dive.

Utility Dive

DOE has no 'regulatory or statutory ability' to create coal, nuclear bailout, says Perry
https://www.utilitydive.com/news/doe-has-no-regulatory-or-statutory-ability-to-create-coal-nuclear-bailou/556687/
Catherine Morehouse
June 12, 2019

The Department of Energy (DOE) does not have the "regulatory or statutory ability" to create economic incentives for coal and nuclear plants, DOE Secretary Rick Perry told reporters on Tuesday at the 2019 Edison Electric Institute conference in Philadelphia. "FERC would be where I would direct your attention," he said, adding that he was also not aware of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission or the White House making any progress on plans to bail out the fuels. "We're pretty much at the same place we were 12 months ago," he said, though the administration "continue[s] to talk ... very openly" about "an all of the above strategy."

The secretary's comments come three months after the White House Council of Economic Advisors released a report to the president calling for a strategic electricity reserve to save uneconomic plants. And earlier in March, Perry had told reporters a coal and nuclear bailout was not entirely off the table.

 

Electric Light & Power
EEI names Exelon Corp. CEO its new chairman

https://www.elp.com/articles/2019/06/eei-names-exelon-corp-ceo-its-new-chairman.html
06/11/2019
     
Christopher M. Crane, president and CEO of Chicago-based Exelon Corp., today was elected chairman of the board of the Edison Electric Institute (EEI), the national association of investor-owned electric companies. Also elected were two vice chairmen: Ben Fowke, chairman, president, and CEO of Minneapolis-based Xcel Energy, and Gerard M. “Gerry” Anderson, chairman and CEO of Detroit-based DTE Energy. The announcement was made during EEI’s annual convention in Philadelphia. The Institute’s chairmanship rotates on an annual basis, and Crane succeeds Lynn J. Good, chairman, president, and CEO of Charlotte-based Duke Energy.

“On behalf of the entire EEI team, I would like to extend our sincere appreciation to outgoing EEI Chairman Lynn Good for her leadership throughout this past year,” said EEI President Tom Kuhn. “Lynn’s advocacy on key policy issues helped to position our industry for the future, and her focus on customers was instrumental in redefining and transforming the customer experience to ensure that EEI member companies can deliver more tailored energy solutions that meet the unique needs of our diverse customers.”

Power Engineering Magazine

DOE’s Perry: Coal, Nuclear Must Be Saved
https://www.powermag.com/does-perry-coal-nuclear-must-be-saved/
06/12/2019 | Darrell Proctor

Energy Secretary Rick Perry said coal and nuclear power must be part of the nation’s “all of the above” energy strategy, but the Department of Energy (DOE) does not have the “regulatory or statutory ability” to establish economic incentives for struggling U.S. coal and nuclear plants. Perry, who addressed the Edison Electric Institute’s (EEI’s) annual convention in Philadelphia on June 11, said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) would take the lead on creating incentives for any energy resource. Perry spoke with media after his address to convention delegates.

“FERC would be where I would direct your attention,” Perry said when discussing bailouts for coal-fired and nuclear power generation. He said he is not aware that FERC is working on any specific incentive plans. The DOE in 2017 told FERC to mandate that competitive power markets put in place rules to “accurately price” what the DOE calls “fuel-secure” generation.

 

State Impact
PJM, nation’s largest power grid operator, grapples with carbon pricing as states diverge on climate policies
https://stateimpact.npr.org/pennsylvania/2019/06/13/pjm-nations-largest-power-grid-grapples-with-carbon-pricing-as-states-diverge-on-climate-policies/
Marie Cusick
JUNE 13, 2019 | 6:00 AM


PJM Interconnection, the nation’s largest grid operator, manages the flow of wholesale electricity in all or part of 13 Mid-Atlantic and Midwestern states and the District of Columbia. It’s a job that’s become even more challenging recently, as states pursue divergent energy policies — from carbon pricing to creating special subsidies for nuclear plants. PJM is now trying to walk a fine line between respecting states’ rights and figuring out how to incorporate those polices into its wholesale electricity market.

‘It’s gets really complicated’ It’s one reason why PJM launched a new senior task force in April to examine state carbon policies. A central focus when the group meets later this summer will be “leakage” — an issue that can drive up costs and undermine the very climate goals states want to achieve.

In Ohio.

News Clips – June 13, 2019

LTE: House Ignores Fact That Clean Energy Is Cheaper (Canton Repository, June 12)

LTE: House Ignores Fact That Clean Energy Is Cheaper (Columbus Dispatch, June 12)

FES Presses Senators for Quick Decision on Nuclear Subsidies (Gongwer News Service Ohio, June 12)

LTE: Pass Nuke Bill (Toledo Blade, June 13)

LTE: Supporting H.B. 6, Rep. Edwards Chooses Party Over People (Athens News, June 12)

Senate Continues to Alter State Budget as Deadline Looms (Columbus WCBE-NPR, June 12)

DOE’s Perry: Coal, Nuclear Must Be Saved (POWER Magazine, June 12)

Senate President: $340 Million in Tax Cuts, Changes in Our Budget (Statehouse News Bureau, June 12)

DOE Has No ‘Regulatory or Statutory Ability’ to Create Coal, Nuclear Bailout, Says Perry (Utility Dive, June 12)

LTE: HB 6 Is Good for Ohio (Wood County Sentinel-Tribune, June 12)

LTE: Reject HB6 to Protect Ohio’s Natural Heritage (Columbus Dispatch, June 11)

Senate Committee Facing Deadline on Nuclear Bailout Bill (Columbus Dispatch, June 11)

Senators Begins Dissecting Nuclear Subsidy Bill (Gongwer News Service Ohio, June 11)

Ads Link FirstEnergy Solutions to Dark Money Group Generation Now Inc. (Energy and Policy Institute, June 11)

Opinion: Closing the Door on Renewable Energy is Bad News for Rural Ohio (Cincinnati Enquirer, June 10)

LTE: Reject HB6 to Protect Ohio’s Natural Heritage (Columbus Dispatch, June 11)